It was also speculated that the party was meant to be the couple's wedding, but it appeared to be about their engagement.
She said: "I've never had a wedding before". She has yet to confirm, however, that they Wednesday leaving her fans guessing.
For the evening, Gwyneth rocked a wine-colored Giambattista Valli Paris dress and a pink corsage on her wrist. We feel like the luckiest people on the planet because we have you in our lives.More news: Domino's will deliver pizza to the beach
More news: Russia Denies Tampering With Syria Chemical Attack Site
More news: Blue Jays-Royals cancelled by roof damage from falling ice
The traditional attire of the bride, in their opinion, brought mom Paltrow at the entrance to the theatre Blythe Danner was spotted with a garment bag, which bore the logo of a wedding designer Monique Lhuillier.
And Paltrow can't believe her former Glee boss pulled off such a great bash.
One person who was notably absent from the festivities was Chris Martin - ex-husband to Gwyneth and co-parent to their two children - Apple and Moses - but given the nature of the event, it makes sense.